Social security myths

Myth Busters: Five Common Misbeliefs about Social Security Claiming

Social Security claiming decisions are a crucial component of your financial plan. Making the wrong assumptions about how the system works can negatively impact the value of your benefits over time, often irreversibly. Don’t fall for these myths when crafting your Social Security benefit claiming strategy.

MYTH #1: Social Security won’t be there for me when I retire.

Yes, there are funding problems for Social Security. Most of the issues stem from the number of workers versus the number of claimants. When Social Security began in 1935, there were about 16 people contributing to the fund for every one person drawing from it. Now there are around three people working for every claimant. But the system can and will be fixed. Too many Americans rely on Social Security to fund a substantial portion of their retirement. So while the payout rules might change a little, and it’s possible younger generations might see lower checks, there will still be Social Security benefits far into the future.

MYTH #2: The Social Security Administration will give me advice about when to claim benefits.

Most consumers don’t realize that the agents at the Social Security Administration are prohibited by policy from giving advice about when you should claim benefits. They can answer technical questions, provide benefit amounts for various claiming ages, and help you with the application process. But they can’t – nor should you want them to – give you advice about one of the most significant financial decisions of your retirement. Unfortunately, while the agents are working very hard, many don’t understand the rules and the claiming options you have.

MYTH #3: I should claim benefits as soon as possible—I’ll receive more checks, so I’ll get more money overall.

While many people believe this myth, it is not true if you live to a normal life expectancy. Sure, you’ll receive more checks if you claim early, but waiting to claim means substantially larger checks each month – and more in cumulative benefits. Here’s an example:

Let’s assume your full retirement benefit (corresponds to the age at which you are eligible to receive your full benefit with no reductions) is $2,000 and you will live to age 85.*

Benefit at age 62: $1,500Cumulative at age 85: $414,000
Benefit at age 66: $2,000Cumulative at age 85: $456,000
Benefit at age 70: $2,640Cumulative at age 85: $475,200

*Examples assumes a birth date of January 2 and a full retirement age of 66.


You can clearly see that waiting means a lot more in benefits. What’s more, if you’re married, waiting until later to claim can afford you additional opportunities that can mean substantially more money for you and your spouse because you can take advantage of special rules available to married couples.

MYTH #4: I should claim benefits early and invest the money.

There have been times in history when this might have made sense – at least short term. But we’ve been in a relatively low interest rate environment for a few years. According to most analysts, it would take a return on the investment of at least 8% — net of fees – for claiming early and investing the money to make sense. And that would have to be a consistent return on the money year over year. The other flaw in this myth is that many people who use this strategy never actually invest the money. Most people are far better off to delay taking benefits, even if it means using your savings to live on until you start your Social Security benefits.

MYTH #5: I should claim my benefits early because I might not live long enough to break even.

None of us knows how long we will live. But the reality is that people are living longer, healthier lives. If you’re married, life expectancy tables indicate there’s about a 3% chance that neither of you will live beyond age 73. But there is a 76% chance that at least one of you will still be alive at age 83. Do you want to make a choice that works out to be the best 3% of the time or 76% of the time? Claiming early not only reduces your cumulative lifetime payout should you live a long life, but it also reduces the survivor benefit.

The Social Security claiming decision is not an easy one, and there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Your best course of action is to work with your financial advisor to determine a claiming strategy that looks across ranges of life expectancies and considers your entire financial picture to help you claim in the way that makes the most sense for your situation. At HTG, we are equipped to review and recommend claiming decisions that can be materially impactful in the context of your overall financial plan.

Source: Social Security Solutions, Inc.

Barbara M. Ollinger, CFP®

Barbara joined HTG in 1998. As a senior advisor, she counsels clients on their financial planning concerns and designs and implements investment portfolios to meet her clients’ objectives.

Barbara has been a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ practitioner since 2007. She received her BS in Business Administration from the University of Maine and her MBA from the University of Connecticut.
The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice and it should not be relied on as such. It should not be considered a solicitation to buy or an offer to sell a security. It does not take into account any investor’s particular investment objectives, strategies, tax status or investment horizon. You should consult your attorney or tax advisor.
Receive our latest features, news and helpful advice